DAVID GLICK, PRIVATE DICK
The Case of the Missing Momma
Conclusion
It didn’t take a genius to understand that Arnold was the key to this mystery. Find Arnold and you find Katrina’s mother Laurina, or find out what happened to her. If she is dead Arnold either killed her or knows who did. It seemed to me that finding him shouldn’t be that big of a deal. Lawyers can’t easily disappear, assuming they continue to practice law.
The next morning I wandered over to Perko’s office about 9:00. His secretary, Ruth Ann, told me to just go in. I flirted with Ruth Ann sometimes, and she had done some internet stuff for me as a favor. I went into Perko’s office and found him there with his feet on the desk, a huge coffee mug within reach. He was reading the Denver Post sports page.
“Well David! And how did you make out with the new client, if the question isn’t too personal?” He didn’t take his feet off the desk and barely looked away from the newspaper. He was wearing an ugly tie, short-sleeved shirt and suspenders.
“I don’t make out with clients, Perko. At least I haven’t yet, but who knows, she could be an exception. Something I need to ask you about. Do you remember a local shyster name of Arnold, maybe twenty years ago?”
Perko told me that Conrad Arnold disappeared shortly after Perko started practicing in town. There was a lot of local gossip and the consensus was that a woman was involved. Arnold had a couple of partners, Strand and Speken, and he really put them in a bind when he left. They had to take over all the clients he was working with and that made for a mess. Strand left town long ago but Speken, who was retired, still lived here. Arnold’s wife was still in town as well. Perko said that she never believed that Arnold ran out on her. She thought the mafia had killed him. I was beginning to notice a pattern.
“Anything to that?” I asked Perko. “Any chance the mob whacked Arnold?”
“Hell, Dave, there’s no mob presence in this town and there hasn’t been for as long as I’ve been here, and that’s 1985. Maybe in the old days, but a long time ago. She’s kidding herself. I don’t know the reason Arnold disappeared himself but I would bet my Bojon butt that’s what he did. Where he got to, who knows? But that’s what that little sweetie is paying you to find out, right?”
I found a number for Arnold’s wife and called her. There was a long pause after I told her that I wanted to meet her to talk about her husband but curiosity won out and she agreed to see me that afternoon. I returned the call of an insurance company manager I had done some work for a few months ago. He had a disability claim he was suspicious about and he wanted me to tail the guy to determine just how disabled he was. Back problems, is what the claim was about. I told him I would do it tomorrow because I was busy today. When it was close to noon I drove over to the Pass Key Drive In and picked up a couple of Pass Key specials with fries and drove back to Vito’s. I put the sack on some newspaper on the floor of the car because I knew the grease from the sausage would leak through the waxed paper the sandwiches were wrapped in and through the brown sack too.
When he saw me walk through the door Vito popped the cap on a Pabst for me and a Bud for himself and we ate at the bar. There weren’t any customers yet. Sinatra’s voice came over the jukebox. Love and Marriage.
“I really don’t like that song,” Vito said.
“Why not?”
“It’s not the man’s kind of song. Not a ballad, not a saloon song. It’s a cute piece of crap. But it plays more than any other song.”
“Why don’t you remove it from the jukebox?”
“Scared to.”
After we finished eating I used a toothpick I had grabbed at Pass Key to dislodge a bit of sausage and I asked Vito about the Pueblo mafia. He told me stuff his father, uncles Calogero and Vincenzo, and even his grandfather had told him. Most of the Pueblo Italians came from Sicily. They left the old country at the end of the 19th Century and the beginning of the 20th to work in the smelters and the steel mill. Some of them brought the old ways with them. Prohibition became the law in Colorado in 1919, a year before the rest of the country. Pueblo was a city with a lot of single men whose women hadn’t been brought over from Europe yet, and many of them were drinkers. Bootlegging took off like a rocket and rival gangs fought each other for the action. When the Volstead Act was repealed in 1933, all of that ended and things calmed down, but when World War II started everything heated up again and the town was wide open. There was an Air Base near town and and Army Camp forty miles away. These guys, along with the steelworkers, had money to spend and prostitution and gambling took much of it. The mafia controlled vice in the city and paid off the law. This lasted until the middle 1960’s when the citizens demanded and got change from local politicians. The old mafiosi retired and died off. They didn’t want their sons to have the lives they did and the sons went to college or into the mill. By 1975 it was all over.
“Anybody telling you the mafia did murder in 1987, well, it just didn’t happen, Dave. Any of those guys still alive by then, they were old, and anyway, what reason would they have to do it? Nah, you’re getting bad info. Look someplace else.”
It hadn’t sounded right to me from the get-go, and after talking to Perko and Vito I was pretty sure that it wasn’t the mob that had killed or chased off Arnold and Laurina. Maybe Arnold’s wife thought that her husband had been murdered by the mob or maybe it was just a smokescreen on her part. You know what? People are duplicitous. I’m not certain what that word means but I think I do, and I like saying it.
The Arnold house was on the north end of the city, on Greenwood, a perfectly named street. The trees planted more than a hundred years ago, when people counted on shade instead of AC to cool their homes, were close to a hundred feet tall. The houses were large and had front porches, but I didn’t see any people sitting on them. The one I was looking for was on a corner with a big lot and when I pressed the doorbell it emitted an annoying buzz. The door was open and a little yapping mutt ran up to the screen door. I don’t mind a big woofer but these little pooches no bigger than a doberman’s turd drive me up the wall. I learned a long time ago that if you growl gruff and loud at these mini-dogs they will shut up and back away, and that’s what I did. That little bastard acted like he had just seen Cujo and he did a u-turn and took off for the rear of the house. Just then Mrs. Arnold came to the door and looked me over up and down. I don’t think she liked what she saw. She was maybe a little hard of hearing. She hadn’t heard the growl.
“What did you do to my dog?”
“Animals sense that I represent danger. They fear me.”
She was a stout woman, probably about 70, who looked like she was capable of kicking my butt and the expression on her face indicated she wouldn’t mind doing it. She didn’t have a good first impression of me. That’s not unusual. She left me standing with the screen door between us long enough for me to use a line I had been saving for years.
“Can I come in? I feel like a fly out here.” It was from an old movie with Robert Mitchum based on a Raymond Chandler novel. Maybe Farewell My Lovely. I’ve always loved private eye movies. None of them are even close to being real but I still like them.
She finally let me in and went to the back of the house to let the dog out without telling me where she was going. It gave me a chance to look around. The living room was just off the foyer where I was standing. I walked over to a bookcase and looked at some of the pictures. There was one of the Arnolds on their wedding day and some others of the two of them, but no pictures of children. Conrad Arnold was a tall, good looking guy, at least when these pictures were taken. In the pictures of the two of them together he wasn’t smiling. Mrs. Arnold came back into the room and asked me to sit down but didn’t offer me any refreshment. She didn’t seem like the small-talk type so I got down to it.
“As I told you on the phone, I’d like to ask a few questions about your husband.”
“My deceased husband.”
“Your deceased husband?”
“Conrad died in 1987.”
“I wasn’t aware of that. My condolences. What happened to him?”
“He was murdered.”
“Murdered! That’s terrible! How was he killed?”
“I don’t know. The body was never found.”
“Who was convicted of the crime?”
“Nobody. The crime is still unsolved.”
I paused and gave her a long look. She didn’t blink. “Mrs. Arnold, if there was no body and if no one was convicted of killing him, how can you be so certain he was murdered?”
“Because it’s the only thing that makes sense. Conrad loved me with all his heart. He would never have left me voluntarily. If he had been kidnapped there would have been a ransom demand. If he had amnesia he would have eventually shown up. He had to have been killed.
“Is there a chance he left you for another woman?”
“None. He knew that if he did I would have found him, reached my hand down his throat and pulled his lungs out.”
“So you are saying that his motivations for staying were love and fear?”
“Exactly. In that order.”
“What about his car? Did it disappear with him?”
“No. They found it in the parking lot near his office where he always parked.”
“What about his clothes, belongings?”
There was a small hesitation before she didn’t answer the question. “You told me you are a private investigator, but who hired you? Why are you asking these questions so many years after Conrad’s death?”
“Naturally, I can’t reveal my client’s name, but I can tell you it is someone who is trying to locate a loved one, and who believes Mr. Arnold’s disappearance and the other person’s disappearance are linked.”
“The family of that slut.”
“Which slut is that?”
“The slut who worked for Conrad. The one some people said he had a fling with.”
“He didn’t, though?”
“He assuredly didn’t! Conrad loved me.”
“I have one other question. Who do you think murdered Conrad?”
“It was the mafia. He had defended some of those animals in prior years. They may not have been happy with his representation. Or maybe they thought he charged them too much. Those people know how to dispose of bodies so they are never found. Yes. It was the mafia.”
A few minutes later I stood up to leave. Mrs. Arnold put her hand on my arm at the door and squeezed my bicep. It hurt.
“If you find out what happened to him, or even if you find out he’s still alive, you must tell me.”
“I’m sorry. You’re not my client. But I promise you that I will speak to my client, and if my client agrees, I’ll tell you what I found.”
After speaking to Perko, Vito, and Mrs. Arnold I now had a theory about Conrad Arnold’s disappearance. It was not original. It was the same theory everyone with the exception of Mrs. Arnold had, and I wasn’t sure about her either. Conrad started getting some action on the side. He and Laurina fell in love. She left town without telling anyone, he left two weeks later. They met up wherever it was they planned to meet, possibly changed identities, and lived happily ever after. Or didn’t. But I had no doubt that they were together after they left Pueblo. I did, however want to talk to Conrad’s former law partner, Dowell Speken. If he had another take I wanted to hear it.
*
Speken lived on the other side of town, but it only took 15 minutes to drive there. It was another neighborhood with tall trees and old, well-kept houses. Probably it had been the best part of town fifty years earlier. I hadn’t called ahead and I drove up to the house listed in the phone book. It was on Ditmer, a brick ranch with a large picture window. A man came to the door even before I rang the bell. When I told him who I was he let me in without asking questions. His bald head was fringed with black hair mixed with gray. His eyes were black but friendly. A woman was in the kitchen watching a small TV while she did something with food. She didn’t look in.
“Mr. Speken, I have been hired to locate someone, and I believe that Conrad Arnold has information that will help me. I’d like to ask a few questions about him.”
“Who are you trying to find?”
“I can’t tell you that. It’s confidential client information.”
“Is it Laurina’s family?”
I paused just long enough for him to know that he had scored a bullseye, then told him again that I couldn’t tell him.
“So those kids grew up and want to know what happened to their mother. That’s understandable, since she left the poor children without explanation. What’s your theory?”
“I’ve heard rumors that the mafia killed them both.”
“That’s bullshit and I think you know it.”
“Some people think Arnold and Laurina ran off with each other. What do you think?”
“Mr. Glick, Conrad and Jeanine had an unhappy marriage. That’s not unusual. But Conrad was afraid of Jeanine. He thought that if he asked her for a divorce she would kill him. Whether she was capable of that, I don’t know, I didn’t know her that well, but Conrad thought so and that’s all that matters. When Laurina came to work for us there was an immediate attraction, even though Conrad was many years older. Everyone in the office knew they were having an affair. When Laurina stopped coming to work we asked Conrad where she was but didn’t get an answer. Two weeks later, when he didn’t show up at the office and Jeanine didn’t know where he was, we all figured it out immediately. I never heard from him again, and that surprised me, as he had an interest in the partnership practice and I assumed he would ask for his money.”
“Did Jeanine get the proceeds from his share?’
“Yes. She had him declared dead three years later. She got his share and she had inherited some family money and she has done all right for herself.”
“Since there was no evidence of foul play, I would think it would have been difficult to have Conrad declared dead.”
“Not if you play bridge with the judge’s wife every Tuesday.”
“What about life insurance? Wouldn’t the insurance company have searched hard for him before they paid out?”
“Mr. Glick, insurance companies look only at the bottom line. If the policy was for a million they would move heaven and earth looking for Conrad before they paid the policy. If it was $100,000, they might think it more cost effective to just pay off.”
I finally asked the most important question, the only one I really cared about being answered.
“Where would you look for Conrad and Laurina if you wanted to find them?”
There was a long pause while he stared at me and thought about his answer. “I don’t know if is wise to find them after all this time. I know Laurina’s kids want answers, but they very well might not like what they learn.”
“I appreciate what you are saying, Mr. Speken, but with all due respect, I don’t think that you have the right to make that decision for them. If they want to find out what happened to their mother, whether they want to meet with her or not, they should have that knowledge.”
There was another long, thoughtful pause, and then the elderly man rubbed his face with his stubby fingers and said, “I would look in Idaho. Conrad grew up there and spoke fondly of it.”
“Wouldn’t Jeanine have looked for him there?”
“Jeanine never looked for Conrad. If he was with another woman, I don’t think she wanted to find him. She would have been humiliated. She felt she was better off thinking of him as dead.”
*
I planned to surveil the disability applicant for my insurance company client the next day. I went by my office after I left Speken. By the time I got there Perko’s door was closed and it was dark inside. I wrote out a note to his secretary, Ruth Ann, asking her to see if she could find out anything about Conrad Arnold or Laurina in Idaho by checking out the Internet. I wrote that I would buy her dinner at Giacomo’s if she got me good information. I slipped it under the door, knowing she would get there before Perko and he wouldn’t see it.
The next morning I was sitting in my car four houses down from a two-bedroom frame house that was more brown than white because most of the paint had peeled off. I had a 16 ounce cup of coffee from Solar Roast on Main Street in my hand and both the Pueblo Chieftain and Denver Post on the seat next to me. I got there at 8:00 to follow the guy who had applied for disability that my client the insurance company wanted checked out. One thing about surveillance – it gives you time to think. I had no doubt now that Conrad and Laurina had run off together. She must have left town, probably didn’t go far, maybe just up the road 40 miles to Colorado Springs, might have stayed with a friend for a couple of weeks, then picked Conrad up and they traveled to wherever they had planned to go. The cops certainly figured this out immediately and didn’t look for them as they hadn’t committed a crime. Mrs. Arnold knew too, although she is still pretending that she doesn’t. Only Laurina’s parents were taken in by the silly ruse, and probably only because they couldn’t believe that Laurina could leave like that. When they hired the private investigator and he started snooping around word got back to Laurina somehow, and she sent the threatening note that ended the search for her. We all suffer our demons, but what had latched on to Laurina that would cause her to leave her kids and let them and her parents think she had died? To never contact them as they grew up. Did she wonder about them? Did she ever come back and wait outside their home, hoping for a glimpse? Or did she just forget them? Was it simply a case of falling so hard in love with Arnold that she was willing to give up everything, even her kids? Or was it something darker, a depression so hurtful that she was afraid that if she didn’t leave she would cause them more harm than she did by leaving. There is no limit on the things people will do to get what they want, or to run from what is chasing them. There were a couple of cases in Seattle that still give me nightmares. In 1995 a mother took her two little kids down to the pier. She tied both of them to herself, then she tied a cinder block to the three of them and jumped off. In the other case, a guy had a fling with a woman he worked with and fell hard for her. He had a wife and three kids. He knew that paying child support would ruin him financially and he took out insurance policies on his whole family and one night when he was supposed to be on a business trip he set the house on fire. The wife burned up trying to save the kids. She threw two of them out of a second floor bedroom window but they were so burned that they died anyway. I was first on the scene and saw her throw them out and helped the firemen douse the flames and heard them screaming while their skin came off. There is nothing you can imagine that humans aren’t capable of doing. So Laurina leaving her kids to think she was murdered isn’t that big a stretch.
At 9:45 I saw the door to the little house open and a man using a cane came out and walked to the Chevy parked in the carport. Even from where I was sitting I could see the hurt on his face. I snapped a couple of pictures and followed him to a physical therapy clinic. He came out after about thirty minutes and drove back home and hobbled in the house. I stuck around until 4:00 and he never came back out. Not everybody filing for disability is a phony son of a bitch.
There was a manila envelope on the floor when I opened my office door. When I took out the contents there was a note on top from Ruth Ann that read, “Pick me up Saturday night at 6. Get a haircut.” She had found Conrad and Laurina in Lewiston, Idaho on the Washington border. In the envelope there were newspaper articles about Conrad selling his insurance agency and retiring, about Laurina doing volunteer work for Meals on Wheels, and them celebrating their wedding anniversary. There were pictures. It was them. Ruth Ann had copied documents about their house from the county assessor and other public records she had found. I read it all, then read it again. There was a phone listing for Conrad. I dialed the number. An elderly man answered and I asked for Laurina. He asked who was calling and I told him never mind who’s calling, just put her on. When she said hello I just ran with it.
“Mrs. Arnold my name is Glick. I’m a private investigator from Pueblo. I was hired by your daughter to locate you and I guess I have.”
There was a long pause before she said anything.
“What do you want?”
“I don’t want a damned thing and I don’t know if Katrina does either, but I would like to know if you will agree to talk with her or meet with her if that is what she wants.”
“No.”
“That’s it? You haul ass, make your kids think you are dead, never contact them, and now that they are grown you won’t even speak to them?”
“What possible good would it do now? What would we say to each other? I doubt Katrina would throw her arms around me and hug me, do you? I think it would be best if it all stays in the past, for her and the other two to get on with their lives and leave me to mine. It’s been too long and too much has happened. They will never forgive me. Tell me what you want. Tell me how much you will take to tell her you can’t find me. I’m willing to pay a reasonable amount.”
“I don’t operate that way. I don’t sell out my clients. I’m going to tell her where you are and she can decide for herself what to do next. If I were her I would write you off and forget you, but that decision is up to her.”
I hung up and called Katrina and told her I had some information and would come by her house at 7:00. Then I looked for used computers in the classifieds.
This is a strange town. The way it works here, your parents either live on the south side or the north side, the two parts of town divided by the Arkansas River. If you grow up on the north side, if you stay in town (and many people do) when you become an adult you live on the north side. Same for the south-siders. Except for high school sports there is no antagonism or competitiveness between the two sides. I’ve asked a few people why it’s like this. Nobody knows. When I moved here I rented a 70 year-old bungalow on the south side. Katrina lives in a similar house. When I walked up to the door, the sun not down and the heat of the day not subsided, I could see Katrina through the open door. She was sitting on the couch watching television. I knocked lightly and she turned off the TV and came toward me. She was wearing shorts, a sleeveless top and sandals and she was gorgeous. She invited me in and I made a point of sitting on the couch next to her. I opened the brown envelope and showed her the pages Ruth Ann had printed and waited while she read them. When she was done I broke the news that I had spoken to Laurina and she had no wish to meet with her. We were only a couple of feet apart and when her tears spilled out of those beautiful eyes I moved over and held her while she sobbed. After a couple of minutes she got up and was gone for a little while, then came back and she was composed. She didn’t sit and she thanked me for all I had done. I asked her what she planned to do and she said she didn’t know yet, she wanted to think about it, it had all come together so fast. I got up, took her little hand and wished her well, kissed her on the cheek, and left.
I do my best thinking when I am driving, and so I drove through the shady streets of twilight and then total darkness. I knew that although I had fantasized about a relationship with Katrina she had no similar thoughts about me. Her mother had left her for an older man. Wouldn’t that fact alone preclude her from wanting anything to do with me? In our two meetings she had never given any clue that she wanted anything from me except a business relationship. I had to respect that. Still, the memory of holding her sweet form, of smelling again that certain perfume… But what the hell. It wasn’t to be.
In this business, mostly there aren’t happy endings. The information you supply clients sometimes ends marriages, sometimes puts people in jail. The worst part is that every once in a while you don’t know the ending. Did Katrina ever call her mother? Did they meet, reconcile? Or did she try to forget Laurina and go on with her life? I wish I knew. I forgot about my promise to Mrs. Arnold to ask Katrina if it was OK to let her know where Conrad was. I didn’t owe her anything and I honestly didn’t think she really wanted to know. Conrad had been dead to her for a long time.
I ended up at Vito’s Bar and Grill. From outside I could hear Sinatra’s voice, Night and Day. It was Friday night and many of the after work crowd had stuck around and the joint was busy and loud. There was an empty stool to the left of the doorway and as I moved toward it I noticed a guy sitting alone at the end of the bar. He was wearing an old-fashioned cloth cap, a cigarette between his brown fingers. There was a small tumbler of beer in front of him but Vito serves beer in mugs. The guy was looking at me with an angry expression on his dark features. I don’t know if he didn’t approve of me, of the people in the bar in general, or of the 21st Century. He looked hazily familiar. Vito was serving a customer at the other end and I waved my arms to get his attention, then pointed back to where the stranger was sitting. I could read Vito’s lips ask, “what?” and he held his hands out in a gesture that said the same thing. When I looked back to the left the stool at the end was empty. No glass on the bar, no pack of Luckies and Ronson lighter that had been there before. Only a thin line of smoke that quickly dissipated in the night air.
Vito Bucchinfuso is the best friend I have in this town. At least once a week we have a late breakfast together before he opens, and frequently on Monday when the joint is closed he invites me to dinner with his wife and kids. I stop by Vito’s for a beer when I have a chance, but I honestly would rather not. I’ve been in some tight spots over the years and I have never backed down when things were tough. I just don’t like to go up against what I don’t understand. That includes the Sicilian sitting at the end of the bar that night. Who was that guy?
Jerr Miller